Tiny Hours, Big Flavor: Wisconsin’s Best Sandwich Found at 4-Hour Eatery

Imagine a restaurant that operates for just four hours a day yet manages to sell out its offerings. This unique establishment has recently been crowned the best place for a sandwich in Wisconsin.

Yelp posted a list of the Best Sandwiches in Every State and said this Wisconsin hotspot is the best.

At Casetta Kitchen and Counter, a place that has caught Yelp's attention, the "Paradigm"  reigns supreme. This sandwich is a favorite among patrons, featuring spicy soppressata, mozzarella, homemade spicy tomato vinaigrette, arugula, and roasted peppers.

If your mouth is watering after reading that, you're not alone.

Casetta Kitchen and Counter has a 4.6 out of 5 Yelp review score, and people like Vela S. say they were "drooling" just thinking about the Paradigm.

While IIa S. praises the 'Paradigm' as their favorite, they also note the restaurant's size, referring to it as 'small.' This mixed feedback adds an element of intrigue to the dining experience.

Despite that complaint, Allison N. says there was "plenty of indoor seating with small patio seating."

Keep Reading: Hungry? This Illinois Food Challenge Is One of America’s ‘Wildest’

The only gripe in that review was the hours of operation at Casetta Kitchen and Counter.

Bao N., who lives in Madison, according to their profile, called Casetta Kitchen and Counter "kind of overrated."

Is Casetta Kitchen and Counter overrated, underrated, or appropriately rated? The answer may vary depending on individual preferences and experiences. It's best to try it yourself and form your own opinion.

You can try it at Casetta Kitchen and Counter, 222 West Washington Avenue, Suite 30, in Madison.